"Nathaniel Bandy, every time" is a joke in which SimpleFlips edits a stream in post to zoom into a detail (such as a Scuttlebug) that he ostensibly didn't notice at the time. Said object almost invariably turns out to be fellow Minus World member Nathaniel Bandy in disguise, prompting the titular catchphrase.
The formulaic setup to this joke has led to a variety of variations and subversions.
Channel Jokes
1, 2 Oatmeal · 200 IQ · Abandoned Children · Adhesive · BUP · Eediot · Fred · Gay Baby Jail · I Can Fly · Ram Ranch · Roxanne · Shoutouts to SimpleFlips · No Cock Like Horse Cock
Stream Jokes
50-50 Grind · Banger · C O O L · Companion P · First Try, Idiot! · Great Entertainer He Is · SimpleFlips Screaming · Speedrunners Hate Him · T-Spin · Garbage
Cursed Bangers
Banger · 1, 2 Oatmeal · Ram Ranch · Roxanne · SimpleFlips Screaming · No Cock Like Horse Cock · I Can Fly
Community Jokes
0.5x A Presses · Aching Tentacles · Bomb Clip · Counter · Dad · Need it as my Ringing Tone · Owless · Press A To Be Gay Today · Pringles Can for $100 · Releasio 64 · TJ "Henry" Yoshi · Toss Your Salad · Unmod Ben · Robot 64
Narrators
Carlos · Harry · Narrator vs Text-to-Speech · SimpleFlips' Narrator
BLJ
BLJ · BLJ the Thwomp's Cock · God-BLJ · IRL BLJ
ROM Hacking Jokes
Green Demon · Invisible Walls · Lava · Lazy Texture Packs · Out of Bounds · Quicksand · Reverse Polygons · Teleportation· Chuckya· Horrifying BUP Abominations
Minus World
Nathaniel Bandy Everytime · Scuttlebug Bandy · Striving for Originality