"Nathaniel Bandy, every time" is a joke in which SimpleFlips edits a stream in post to zoom into a detail (such as a Scuttlebug) that he ostensibly didn't notice at the time. Said object almost invariably turns out to be fellow Minus World member Nathaniel Bandy in disguise, prompting the titular catchphrase.

The formulaic setup to this joke has led to a variety of variations and subversions.
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.